Cisco Blogs

Why Privacy will trump Net Neutrality

August 18, 2008 - 7 Comments

With the recent FCC ruling on elements of Net Neutrality, the dog days of summer are witnesses to yet another chapter unfolding in this ongoing debate. Proponents of both sides will end up dissecting the FCC’s final decision line by line, deciding whether this applies to the debate writ large, or is limited to this specific instance. But out on the horizon, storm clouds are forming around a topic that will undoubtedly overshadow the current NN debate. The topic – privacy. It’s risky making these types of predictions in such a public way -it’s always there for comparison – but in this case, a straightforward reason exists in forecast this upcoming squall. Simplicity. People get it, politicians of all stripes understand it, and the mainstream media can wrap their heads around it. Whereas the debate on NN is focused on technology and its different permeations necessary to actively manage rapidly expanding networks, the technology side of privacy is quickly negated when viewed through the lens of falsification or theft of one’s own personal information.It’s far from being a new debate but with a spat of recent high-profile data breaches, the general public has rightful expressed concern. Of course with increased concern, legislators could be compelled into refreshing or creating new privacy measures to allay fears over a perceived lack of protection. What needs to be done? Principally, we need to avoid overreaction. Too often, in our haste to plug holes we rush in and unleash a whole host of unintended consequences. Secondly, we need to continually press business to recognize the importance of privacy and the necessity of implementing measures to protect it. And finally, persist with the ongoing education of consumers and how they can manage and protect their privacy. Naturally, some privacy advocates will claim that the measures above glaze over the whole issue of collecting information based on individual’s internet habits. While it is incumbent upon business and government to provide consumers with meaningful and easy accessible information on what’s being collected, unless it’s being used for duplicitous reasons, there are legitimate reasons for doing so. Records are a necessity for doing business; create an ability to provide increased customer satisfaction levels, and even create worlds of experiences and opportunities that might otherwise remain unexposed or uncreated. It will be healthy to have this debate over the possibilities and potential concerns of privacy, albeit without fear mongering. Openness to what the possibilities can entail, will continue to aid the net’s evolution. On the bright side -and at risk of being flamed for saying so – with legislative and regulatory officials turning their focus towards privacy, the whole NN debate might finally be recognized for what it truly is. A non-issue which will eventually be recognized as a mere snap shot in time of the net’s evolution.

In an effort to keep conversations fresh, Cisco Blogs closes comments after 60 days. Please visit the Cisco Blogs hub page for the latest content.


  1. Nice informative post.

  2. Net should not have any kind of Privacy, we need to do what ever we need in any time and so we go to the NET they dont have to take that from us .

  3. I for one am suprised at how free”” the internet still is in this post terrorism age. I think over the next few years many of the freedoms we take for granted on the net may dissapear. Of course privacy is an important issue but it should not encroach on what makes the internet so good.”

  4. Privacy is a real concern for many consumers. Luckily, many of the larger companies, such a Cisco, are taking their customers concerns seriously. In fact, many of the companies are going beyond what is required of them to allow customers to know exactly what information is being collected.

  5. In regards to privacy, I think Google is a good example of what the right thing to do. They collect all of your searches when you are logged in, BUT, they give you the option to opt out of them collecting your data, they even let you delete this data if you log in.

  6. that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts and article. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon. i think this policy is good for every one.

  7. I think that an addition to privacy, increased security with help overcome the issue of net neutrality.