November 02, 2009

Cisco’s proposed TANDBERG acquisition


At the end of last week, there was some significant speculation and rumor in the media about our offer to acquire TANDBERG, a global leader in video communications.  As a result, I wanted to reiterate a few important points about the transaction and Cisco’s broader M&A principles.

We strongly believe our offer is a very good price for Tandberg shareholders.  We have commenced a cash tender offer, unanimously recommended by the Tandberg Board, to purchase all the outstanding shares of TANDBERG for 153.5 Norwegian Kroner per share for approximately $3.0 billion.  As Tandberg noted in its own communications to the Oslo Exchange, Cisco’s offer represents a 38.3% premium to the closing share price on July 15 - which is one day prior to major media reports of a possible transaction.  The price also represents a 102% 12 month return for Tandberg shareholders, far surpassing global market index returns.

Cisco has established a strong record as an acquirer by creating good returns for shareholders of both the companies it acquires as well as Cisco. This deal is no different - we have focused on ensuring strong returns for Tandberg and Cisco shareholders.  Cisco’s strategy has always been about maximizing value and opportunity while minimizing risks.  The value of the combination of Tandberg and Cisco has been widely covered and discussed, but the risks, from capturing synergies and executing on our first ever acquisition of a European public company, to the overall integration complexity associated with engineering and sales spread across both Norway and the UK, are also important.  We have also been required to consider currency exchange costs which, at the current rates, have added at least $100m to our overall expense.  Our offer price reflects this balance and is based on a simple premise for both sets of shareholders – fairness and value.  Is a 38.3% premium fair for Tandberg shareholders? Absolutely.  Does it lock in a superior return for Tandberg shareholders and protect them from future market risk?  Yes.  Does it also fairly reflect risks borne exclusively by Cisco shareholders? Yes.

The bottom line is that Cisco will always act with fiscal prudence.  The collaboration market is a $34 billion dollar opportunity where voice is currently the largest application.  We believe that video will become the core of the collaboration market, but, it will require substantial innovation and investment to drive this market transition.  We’ve already seen increased competition for the traditional video players in the market, as broad based collaboration vendors increasingly focus on video.  For all these reasons we believe the time is right for Cisco and Tandberg to come together to help accelerate global adoption of collaboration technology through interoperable, standards-based products.  However, no acquisition should be pursued or completed if it runs counter to the broader principles of prudence and financial fairness. 

Given all the speculative “noise” last week, I wanted to take the time to reiterate these points because it is important to me, and to Cisco, that all of our stakeholders understand our position as we near the end of the offer period.

Ned Hooper Posted by Ned Hooper at 10:00AM PST

Permalink, Comments (6), Trackbacks (0)

Tags: acquisitions collaboration m&a tandberg video

6 Comments

Halgeir Bergestuen Nov 3, 2009

Regarding “Cisco’s proposed TANDBERG acquisition”, posted by Ned Hooper.

1.
Since July 15 the main index of the Norwegian stock market (OSEBX) has increased 18 %. Adjusting the Tandberg share price for this, the NOK 153.50 bid price represents a premium of 17.2 %. Hence, referring to a premium of 38.3 % is misleading.

2.
On Thursday September 3, seven weeks after “major media reports of a possible transaction”, the Tandberg closed at 118.90 (+ 7.1 % since July 15), while the Norwegian stock marked had increased 5.3 %. Fairly modest outperformance, given the alleged speculation on a takeover

3.
The day before the offer, Tandberg closed at NOK 138.30 (+ 24.6 % since July 15), while the Norwegian stock marked had increased 15 %. Not particularly eye catching for a company of Tandbergs caliber.

Hence, the breath taking premium one should refer to is 11 % (153.50 versus 138.30).


Kind regards,
Halgeir Bergestuen, CFA
Head of Equity
Oslo Pensjonsforsikring AS

Eric Nov 4, 2009

I hope that this acquisition of TANDBERG helps your stock skyrocket.  I have a part of the stock so I am all for acquisitions that help the share holders.

Brad Nov 9, 2009

It’s November 9, Ned. What has Cisco decided to do?

Cisco Note:  Offer has been extended to November 18.  See press release here: http://newsroom.cisco.com/dlls/2009/corp_110909.html

Brad Nov 9, 2009

Thanks for the reference. About a half hour after I asked the question, the news broke about the extended offer.

It will be interesting to see how the dissident Tandberg shareholders respond. My math says Cisco, if it is to reach the approval threshold of 90 percent of all tendered shares, will need to convince two thirds of the naysayers to change their minds. That’s a tall order.

Cisco’s other options are to sweeten the offer or to walk away.

Halgeir Bergestuen Nov 10, 2009

Follow up on the premium

Since Sept 30 (the day before the offer) the main index of the Norwegian stock market (OSEBX) has increased by 6.4 % (as of close Nov 9). Adjusting the Tandberg share price for this, the offer now represents a premium of 4.3 %.


Kind regards,
Halgeir Bergestuen
Head of Equity
Oslo Pensjonsforsikring AS

Ashley Nov 14, 2009

I say they walk away.  $3B can fund quite a bit of internal development!  Cisco doesn’t need Tandberg’s sales or marketing force anyways!

Post a comment

Join the conversation!

We encourage your comments, questions and suggestions. All comments are moderated and will appear as soon as they are approved by the moderator.

Please increase the validity of your comment by providing a valid first and last name. Spam, off-topic or offensive comments will not be posted.

Name:
Email:
URL:

Comments:

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Post a trackback

Ping this URL to post a trackback:
http://blogs.cisco.com/trackback/8095/4DPSsVLJ/

More blog posts

Previous post:
Cisco Highlights Collaboration with Microsoft’s Latest Windows Products

Next post:
Cisco Announces Agreement to Acquire DVN Set-Top Box Business

Recent posts:
February 2010 Archive