March 13, 2009

What’s the point of Twitter?


I was in NYC last week talking to a number of media-company marketers, and journalists covering the media industry. Inevitably the conversation turned to Twitter and its more recent, explosive growth outside of Silicon Valley.

Most interesting to me was that after glowing introductory comments, I was able to derail almost every conversation flow by asking:  “What’s the point of Twitter? How are you using it, and what is the business objective you’re trying to achieve with it?”  I wasn’t trying to be a jerk; I’m just legitimately interested in why people are using Twitter.

I knew I was on to something when one of the journalists sighed with obvious relief and said:  “Oh good, we were thinking it was just us that couldn’t figure out the point.  We figured you guys in Silicon Valley knew something we didn’t.” 

Nope, sorry; we’re in this boat together. 

So what are companies using Twitter for?
Fair disclosure, I Twitter.  I see value in it.  You can see Tweets about the CMSG business unit and the Cisco Eos platform here

My use of Twitter is 2-fold: 
1) As a distribution amplifier—it’s a content blipvert (minus the chance of explosion) you can use to draw people into an extended conversation if they’re interested. 
2) As a monitoring system—what blipverts are other people putting out there, and what’s interesting to me as an individual or a business.

For me Twitter is then just a conversation starter, not an end to itself.  That seemed to surprise the folks I was talking to.

I don’t know maybe; I’m missing something.  Would love to hear from you:  what’s the point of Twitter, and how do you use it?

Scott Brown Posted by Scott Brown at 03:18PM PST

Permalink, Comments (14), Trackbacks (0)

Tags: cisco eos cmsg twitter

14 Comments

Kaustav Bhattacharya Mar 13, 2009

Great post, Scott.

I’d like to add to the two points you shared with us about your uses of Twitter by adding two more of my own.

1) Using Twitter for collaboration and reaching out to specialists in their field on a global basis who might share in the causes I support and then network with them to make things happen very fast and almost spontaneously.

A great example of this is document at http://bit.ly/10ZB6g - the spontaneity of my Twitter of Twitter to network with amazing people is documented under the heading “Footnote: The Power of Twitter and the ’social web’”.

2) Using Twitter to bring about social change by using it to raise funds and connect with people to mobilize the power of the crowd.

Point two is particularly poignant for a social development project I recently participated in India. Through Twitter we continue to bind together the aspirations of 400+ individuals who took part in an amazing project to expose the youth of India to amazing role models in social entrepreneurship and inspire the youth to become future leaders of scalable, social enterprises.

I also agree with you that Twitter is one of the many tools available to monitor the buzz around a brand, product or service an monitor and therefore react to both positive and negative comments in a far more reactive way.

Scott Brown Mar 13, 2009

Kaustav, makes sense.  But aren’t those examples achievable via other tools?  Is there something completely unique about the Twitter interaction (beyond it’s accessibility and brevity?)

Kaustav Bhattacharya Mar 13, 2009

True, these things are definitely achievable through other means… the most obvious being picking up the phone and calling or sending off an email. I guess for me, the brevity of Twitter itself quite often instigates the spontaneity within the conversation thread and in many cases, for me at least, it fast tracks the real world connection.

Being a news junky in general, I also find Twitter is a great way to get near real time news alerts and then rapidly follow up and keep abreast of things, sometimes faster than the news break on TV/Radio or on blogs. The recent Mumbai terror attacks is a good example, where I was totally unaware of the events that were transpiring just meters away from family who live very close to the hotels that were under attack, but I was alerted to the atrocities within minutes of them happening via eye witness tweets and re-tweet coming from people in the immediate area of the attacks.

There’s something about the bite size 140 character limit that at first seems limiting but somehow, and counter intuitively makes Twitter work much better than if you could post thousands of characters. Twitter fulfills for me that thirst for immediate, bite sized and spontaneous information. I also like the way Twitter is “push” as much as it is “pull” information, depending on how you access Twitter on your PC or mobile.  I tend to keep Twibble permanently loaded in memory on my Nokia N82 which allows me to have Tweets pushed to my attention (although in technical reality the client is pulling the feed down to the mobile device).

That’s a very personal view of how I use Twitter but from a more business perspective, I see many senior execs intelligently using Twitter to promote thought leadership in their area of business. Without overtly pushing their product or service, they Tweet about their industry and point to further discourse on their blogs or article they’ve written elsewhere. It’s a more subtle form of marketing which for me works much better than straight forward and blatant promotion. It draws me in to a conversation rather than just pushing me to a service or product.  Ultimately, Twitter is a conversation starter.

Shruti Bhat Mar 13, 2009

Scott,
Interesting point of view. One may be inclined to think that Twitter is just a feature and not sustainable as a standalone product, but I believe the very fact that it is so simple and lean is what makes it effective.

As an individual I use it to build an online presence - just a microblog thats easy to update. Also, I find that its a great way to keep track of updates from people whose work I am interested in.

As a marketer for ExerciseTV, I see value in eavesdropping on our customers’ conversations about the products and videos. The “influencers” are out there on Twitter - its a great way to feel the pulse of the market. Also, with the increasing amount of email spam, we find that twitter is just one more way to share info about releases and engage with customers.

Chuck Fishman Mar 14, 2009

Scott - There is something completely unique about Twitter, but I’m not sure it can be quantified. That’s why I think it’s okay to ask, “What’s the point of Twitter?”. I asked that for about 8 months of use before I really got into it. My friends on Facebook who see my Twitter updates roll into Facebook by web syndication methods, ask the same thing. This comes up in my conversations a lot because everybody knows I am a huge Twitter advocate.

Look, Eric Schmidt, the CEO of Google, couldn’t even answer what the point of Twitter is - he instead dubbed it “a poor man’s email system” which I think is way off the mark.

On the Twitter search side of the house, search around Twitter buzz topics is real time, versus Google where results need to indexed in the search engine first. That’s interesting to me. I loved watching the dialogue around the Presidential debates in real time on http://election.twitter.com (site is no longer functioning).

Twitter is a community broadcast system, a conversation that happens minute by minute. I have many members of my community there. I feel like every time I log on I learn something new - I call Twitter, “ambient education”. Twitter is also one of my primary media and entertainment experiences. I use Twitter, to connect, discover, and share content, and I talked a little about that here:

1) Connecting:

http://blogs.cisco.com/media/comments/twitter_as_a_media_and_entertainment_experience/

2) Discovery:

http://blogs.cisco.com/media/comments/building_an_entertainment_community_find_your_fans_first/

3) Sharing:

http://blogs.cisco.com/media/comments/share_your_listening_habits_with_the_community/

Scott Brown Mar 16, 2009

Shruti, agree with your comments.  Thanks for contributing (and for identifying that homegrown Eos community).  Cheers.

Craig Apr 1, 2009

For a couple months, we’ve been using Twitter at theMOCK.com’s home page to generally announce current and forthcoming content.  The account has supported development of a global following that would likely have not been achieveable absent spending thousands of dollars on marketing, advertising and paid referrals.  While this speaks to a “poor man’s email”, the Twitter account (Twitter.com/theMOCK) advances branding and indicates the level and reach of our followership, while traditional emails generally do not. 
 
Recently, we started using a Twitter account tightly integrated with a fictional character in an animation series.  We are using the Twitter account to promote the character and series and to message directly from the character to site users. 
Check out our character’s Twitter widget at http://www.twitter.com/ourguyphil.

Scott Brown Apr 1, 2009

Craig, thanks for the comment; interesting use of Twitter.  Completely agree with you that Twitter is an effective channel for reach target audiences. 

You obviously had an objective in mind when you started using Twitter for Phil—and that’s kind of the point:  Twitter is another tool, and not necessarily the cure to all problems.

Cheers.

Human Jun 16, 2009

It’s kind of interesting how twitter is catching up and the debates above. However, I have a very short and concise question. How is twitter different to txt messaging/sms, or instant messaging(im)? These days we carry smart phones which has capability of installing softwares for any im namely gtalk, yahoo, msn, icq, aim, skype - you name it. So why is twitter any better? Is it really a fad? a hype?

Human Jun 16, 2009

Oh and I forgot to mention one thing. Go check out http://wave.google.com/ and then let’s come back to this table and debate about twitter again.

Scott Brown Jun 16, 2009

Human, good question.  One could argue that there is no difference in terms of functionality—the difference really becomes a momentum, marketing, brand issue. 

We can all point to moments where “better” technologies (think VHS vs Beta) were beat by “inferior” technologies by market momentum.

It’s now up to Twitter to execute and continue its differentiation.  The good news for them (at this point) is that they have momentum and everyone is trying to catch up.

The good news for us as tech consumers is that we have more options and opportunities to find what technology works best for our own needs.

Any thoughts on that?

Shruti Jun 16, 2009

Speaking of fulfilling different needs, one of the big differentiators of Twitter (as compared to Facebook, email and IM) is that it is essentially one-way communication. This means it allows those who want to “talk” or those who want to “listen” just do their own thing. To clarify my point, consider an industry expert posting his views or interesting articles and the CEO of a start-up talking about his journey - they neither want to be my FB friends nor my chat buddies but if I’m an interested listener they welcome me as a follower on Twitter. This is different from a blog because all their posts show up on my Twitter home page, I can re-post their messages as RT or I can send them @replies if I have something relevant to say. Besides, the fact that it restricts sentence length really forces people to get to the point and even those who are on-the-go with no time for blogging will readily adopt this micro-blogging option. I personally don’t want my status updates to be seen by the CEOs that I follow - so I’m in “listener” mode but sometimes I do put a shout-out for projects and get amazing support from the community.

Jeremiah Owyang Jul 2, 2009

Yup I agree, it’s a tool (one of many)—for a greater purpose.

Steve Sep 16, 2009

its a pointless exercise…

and thats why it succeeds, because its about ‘dead bang on’ the level of most peoples intellect nowadays.

And given the number of Attention Deficit Disorder cases out there, its about the right text length, before they get bored and move on…

God help us all. (that actually would fit, pity no-one says it)

Post a comment

Join the conversation!

We encourage your comments, questions and suggestions. All comments are moderated and will appear as soon as they are approved by the moderator.

Please increase the validity of your comment by providing a valid first and last name. Spam, off-topic or offensive comments will not be posted.

Name:
Email:
URL:

Comments:

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Submit the word you see below:


Post a trackback

Ping this URL to post a trackback:
http://blogs.cisco.com/trackback/7086/3h6APDuf/

More blog posts

Previous post:
Social Networks & Blogs Increase to # 4 Online Activity

Next post:
Content Freshness - Part 1

Recent posts:
November 2009 Archive